:: domaining business blog // Domaining for Domainers

Archive for the ‘’ Category

AOL Owns, But Can’t Win UDRP

October 14, 2010AOL, Domaining, Domainnamewire, National Arbitration Forum,, Policy & Law, udrpComments Off on AOL Owns, But Can’t Win UDRP

AOL’s lawyers didn’t provide enough evidence of common law rights.

Patch.comAOL owns the web site, yet it has failed to obtain the typo through a National Arbitration Forum proceeding.

How is this possible? It seems that AOL’s lawyers may have taken this case for granted and not supplied enough evidence.

The panel found that is confusingly similar to AOL’s PATCH mark, and that the respondent doesn’t have any rights or legitimate interests in the domain name.

Proving registration and use in bad faith is where AOL tripped up. AOL got the domain name on February 4, 2009. The typo was registered 8 days later. After the typo was registered AOL filed for trademarks. So the panelist looked to any sort of common law rights before was registered on February 12:

…Complainant has failed to provide sufficient evidence of common law rights in the PATCH.COM that would effectively predate Respondent’s registration of the domain name. Therefore, the Panel concludes that Respondent could not have registered the disputed domain name with the requisite bad faith under Policy.

I must say I’m somewhat surprised by this decision. Even if AOL didn’t provide the necessary information, 9 out of 10 panelists would have transferred the domain.

© 2010.

Get Certified Parking Stats at DNW Certified Stats.

Related posts:

  1. Fun and games with UDRP
  2. Sharing Domain Parking Stats is Easy with DNW Certified Stats
  3. Two New Cases Show What’s Wrong with UDRP